wiseseo:~/news/gsc-ai-opt-out-impressions-vs-clicks $

date
category
[AI]
impact
MED
status
CONFIRMED
read
4 min

A site left AI Overviews and lost the impressions. Clicks barely moved.

Brodie Clark says one site that excluded itself from AI Overviews and AI Mode in Search Console lost hundreds of thousands of daily impressions, while clicks barely changed.

TL;DR

  • Clark says a site that excluded itself from AI Overviews and AI Mode lost hundreds of thousands of daily impressions, while clicks barely moved.
  • The Search Console control also covers generative AI in Discover. Exclude is not a ranking signal for the rest of Search.
  • The post names no site, click count, or switch date, and the Generative AI report has no click column.
  • Before an Exclude test, export Generative AI impressions, log the property and date, wait 1-2 days, and compare Web clicks separately from Discover.

Brodie Clark wrote on LinkedIn on 22 November 2026 that a site had removed itself from Google's generative AI features with the Search Console controls:

This site has completely excluded itself from generative AI features (AI Overviews and AI Mode) using the new AI controls in GSC. Hundreds of thousands of daily impressions are gone. The result on clicks? Barely even noticeable.

The post names no site, no click count, and no switch date. He adds that Google needs to make the features more valuable to websites. The only scale in the post is hundreds of thousands of impressions a day.

That setting is the Search generative AI control, on every website as of 31 August 2026, under Settings, then Search generative AI. It covers AI Overviews, AI Mode, and generative AI in Discover. Include, the default, allows links, grounding, impressions, and traffic. Exclude blocks the site's links and content in those features, including as grounding for the response, and Google says the site then gets no traffic and no impressions from them. Child properties inherit unless an owner overrides them.

What exclusion leaves alone

A change generally takes a few days. Content drops within 1-2 days after the control goes live, longer where caching applies. It is not a ranking or inclusion signal for the rest of Search. Merchant Center and Google Ads stay as they are. Google-Extended is the training control, and noindex still removes a URL from Search.

nosnippet, in the robots meta tag spec, is page-level. It blocks a text snippet across web search, Images, Discover, AI Overviews, and AI Mode, and blocks that page as a direct input for the two AI features. The Search Console control is property-wide, blocks grounding, and leaves ordinary snippets alone.

What you can measure

The Generative AI performance report for Search counts how often a link was shown to a user in AI Overviews or AI Mode, by page, country, device, date, and search type, including Lens. Search Labs is omitted. An exclusion can leave too few impressions for the report to show.

The 3 June 2026 announcement lists the same cuts. Clicks and queries are absent, with further metrics still undecided. Those impressions also sit inside the overall Performance report: the AI report draws on the Web search type, and its chart counts two links from one site in one AI feature as one impression. Impression rules count a link on the current results page even if it was not scrolled into view, unless a click is required to reveal it. A click to an external page lands on the Performance report, and an AI Mode follow-up is a new query. Clark does not say whether he watched Web clicks, Discover, or analytics.

How to read the gap

"Hundreds of thousands" a day is Clark's size, on a chart that already merges one site's links inside a single feature. "Barely even noticeable" is his judgment of clicks. With no counts, the post yields no click-through rate. A flat Web click line beside that drop can be a low click rate, or a window too noisy to show a small loss.

Google says other sites stay in the feature and may look similar, so the answer can remain while the link moves. Discover shares the switch on its own report, and Clark named only AI Overviews and AI Mode. No site name and no switch date means a ranking change on the same days cannot be separated from the control. Exclude on a domain covers children that still inherit. A URL-prefix covers that prefix only.

A second opt-out moved clicks the other way. On 30 October 2026, Search Engine Roundtable reported Cyrus Shepard's small case study: about a 0.9% click-through rate on AI impressions, estimated from before-and-after sitewide clicks, regular organic clicks down while excluded, and AI impressions at about 8% of the total. AI Overviews stayed on the page throughout. The site was absent only during the test. The 0.9% is Shepard's estimate, the sites differ, and neither post includes the queries.

what to do

  • Export Generative AI impressions by page, country, and device before any change. There is no click column, and ~ or - exports as zero.
  • On an Exclude test, log the property and the date, wait the 1-2 days Google names, and compare Web clicks under that label. Read Discover on its own.
  • Treat a flat line as no large loss in that window, on one property, and publish the counts.
  • Stay on Include when a missing mention is the risk. Google-Extended limits training. noindex leaves Search. nosnippet also removes ordinary snippets.
  • Resuming old AI Mode threads is a separate change. See Google's collapsible sidebar for recent AI Mode searches.

refs

  1. [1] Brodie Clark on LinkedIn: a site excluded from AI Overviews and AI Modehttps://www.linkedin.com/posts/brodieclark_this-has-been-pretty-eye-opening-to-witness-activity-7530248034346262528-lA5R
  2. [2] Search generative AI control (Search Console Help)https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/16908024?hl=en
  3. [3] Generative AI performance report (Search) (Search Console Help)https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/16984139?hl=en
  4. [4] Introducing Search Generative AI performance reports in Search Consolehttps://developers.google.com/search/blog/2026/06/gen-ai-performance-reports
  5. [5] What are impressions, position, and clicks? (Search Console Help)https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/7042828?hl=en
  6. [6] Robots meta tag specifications (Google Search Central)https://developers.google.com/search/docs/crawling-indexing/robots-meta-tag
  7. [7] Google AI Overviews and AI Mode opt-out study (Search Engine Roundtable)https://www.seroundtable.com/google-ai-overviews-mode-ctr-42421.html