wiseseo:~/news/shepard-backlink-content-formats-study $

date
category
[AI]
impact
MED
status
CONFIRMED
read
2 min

Cyrus Shepard: blog posts earn the fewest natural links

A 535-site Zyppy study finds data trackers and tools earn over 50 times more linking domains per URL than generic blog posts.

Generic blog posts and guides were the weakest natural link earners in a new study by Cyrus Shepard of Zyppy, published on 18 November 2026. Using Ahrefs data, his team picked 535 sites with healthy Google traffic (most with at least 10,000 estimated monthly organic visits), pulled the top link-earning pages on each, nearly 4,000 URLs in all, discounted links that showed signs of manipulation, and grouped the winners by format.

The gap is wide. Data-tracking pages (records and regularly updated data feeds) came in at 1,491 linking root domains per URL, and tools and calculators at 1,466. Glossary and reference pages reached 991. Generic articles and guides finished last, at 28.

"In fact, general articles ranked dead last in link-earning performance, yet businesses seem to spend ~98% of their time producing this type of content."

Across formats, Shepard sees the same traits in the winners: information that is hard to copy, help with finishing a task, visible evidence for the numbers, a narrow focus, and upkeep over several years. In his X post about the study, he adds that writers and journalists link to the same kinds of pages AI answers like to cite: original data, reference material and unique facts.

For how AI answers pick what to cite, see our brief on ChatGPT now links pages it never cites.

Why it matters

A page that only explains something an AI answer can summarize gives nobody a reason to link to it. A page that holds a number, a tool or a reference someone needs to cite still does, for people and for AI answers.

what to do

  • Count how much of last year's content was generic posts versus data, tool or reference pages.
  • Turn one recurring question in your niche into a maintained asset, such as a reference table, calculator or tracked metric, with the method and the last-updated date on the page.
  • Give it a push. Shepard notes the page still has to rank, and some early outreach helps get the first links.

Caveat: this is observational Ahrefs data from sites that already earn traffic, so the per-format link counts show what tends to attract links, not a controlled test.

refs

  1. [1] How to Build Backlinks on Autopilot: 535-Site Studyhttps://signal.zyppy.com/p/seo-backlinks
  2. [2] Cyrus Shepard on X: what content types earned the most linkshttps://x.com/CyrusShepard/status/2123501922682548303